The Harrisons of Pendleton District SC and Franklin County GA


My maternal Harrison line begins with Thomas Harrison and his wife Caty (lnu) who settled on the South Carolina side of the Tugaloo River in the late 1700s.  Thomas was born about 1740, probably in VA, and he died about 1810 in SC.  Some have speculated that Thomas' wife was an Earle but I have found no proof of this.  One researcher claims she was the daughter of Samuel Earle III and his wife Anna Sorrell which would make Caty the sister of Judge Baylis Earle and Colonel John Earle, both of whom were very prominent men in the western part of South Carolina.  The researcher formed that connection due to some proof that Thomas and Caty were living near Samuel Earle on a waterway named Willow Brook in present day Warren County, VA.


Like so many of the early settlers of the Tugaloo River area, Thomas probably was a Revolutionary war veteran but I have not found any definitive proof of his service.  There is a pay record for a Thomas Harrison that served with the SC Militia but the information in the packet is very limited.  There is a headright land grant dated 1785 in Franklin County, GA but it is not a bounty grant.  Given the fact that he lived very close to Col. Benjamin Cleveland in South Carolina and with so many of his children marrying Clevelands, who were together in Wilkes County, NC before moving to the Pendleton area, he may have served with the Colonel in the NC Militia.  Barzilla Harrison, another Harrison that lived along the Tugaloo River close to Thomas Harrison, may be related.  Barzilla's widow filed for a pension after Barzilla died.  Moses Guest was one of the men who attested to Barzilla's service in the war.  Barzilla resided in Surry County, NC when drafted.  Note that Surry County and Wilkes County in NC adjoin -  the same general area where Col. Benjamin Cleveland and Moses Guest were from.


His GA & SC lands appear to have spanned both sides of the Tugaloo River near present day Toccoa & Lavonia, Georgia.  There are numerous land and tax records for a Thomas Harrison on Shoal Creek and Beaverdam Creek.  There are tax records dating well into the mid-1800s for a Thomas Harrison living on Shoal Creek in Franklin County.


CLICK HERE TO SEE ACTUAL LAND PLATS IN PENDLETON DISTRICT, SC



Present day map of the area where the Harrisons lived in Western SC and NE GA
(Key to map is located at the bottom of the page.)
(Bing maps; Annotation by author)


One confusing fact in any research for Thomas is that there was another possibly more prominent Thomas Harrison who was a noted lawyer that practiced in both Pendleton and Greenville around 1800.  This Thomas was likely younger but with limited documents available, keeping them identified separately is a challenge.  We also have numerous Thomas Harrisons that are old enough to be sons and nephews of Thomas and Caty – these too have made research difficult.


I have culled through most of the information available and have come up with the following pertinent information for our direct Harrison line.  


Thomas and Caty had the following children:


1.       
Thomas Jr. married Nancy (lnu).  This is my direct line - see more info below.

2.        Martha Patsy/Patty married Absalom Cleveland the son of Colonel Benjamin Cleveland.

3.        Benjamin married Elizabeth Cleveland who was probably the daughter of Rev. John Cleveland (the brother of Col. Benjamin Cleveland).  Benjamin was one of the co-executors listed in William Cleveland's Will (Benjamin Harrison and William Cleveland were brothers-in-law).

4.        William married Elizabeth Perkins

5.        Nancy Ann married William Cleveland the daughter of Rev. John Cleveland (the brother of Col. Benjamin Cleveland).

6.        John married Naomi (lnu).  John died in 1836 leaving a large family.  His Will can be found on Ancestry.com.

7.        Robert (unknown history), probably had a son named Larkin that married his 1st cousin Frances Harrison, the daughter of Benjamin and Elizabeth Cleveland Harrison.  The wife of Robert was probably Nancy (lnu).


He may have had other children.


SOME PROPERTY RECORDS

The following early records are from the book Pendleton District, S.C. Deeds, 1790-1806, by Betty Willie:


July 1801, Thomas Harrison, Sr., sold 575 acres to William Cleveland on Beaverdam Creek of the Tugaloo River, originally granted to said Harrison in 1786.  Witnessed by ? Cleveland, p. 251


March 1801, for love and goodwill, Thomas Harrison, Sr. transferred property to his son-in-law William Cleveland.  Thomas' wife Caty is noted.  J.D. Terrill is a witness (John D.), p. 266


January 1802, for love and goodwill, Thomas Harrison, Sr. transferred property to his son Robert Harrison.  John D. Terrill is a witness; William Cleveland is noted, p. 280


August 1804, William Harrison sold 200 acres on Big Beaverdam Creek to Thomas Harrison, Sr, land bounded by Pendleton Isbell and others.  Witnesses were Benjamin Harrison and J.D. Terrill.  William Cleveland as J.P., p. 345


No date but probably 1801-1802; for consideration of goodwill and affection to my son Benjamin Harrision grant to him 200 acres on Tugaloo River, signed Thomas Harrison, p. 258


The following are transactions for a Thomas Harrison for which I did not confirm are the same man.


February 1796 – A Thomas Harrison witnessed a property transaction; He made an oath to Nathaniel Perry, p. 129


April 1798, A Thomas Harrison witnessed a land transaction on the SW side of the Saluda River, p. 180


November 1793, A Thomas Harrison and a John Harrison witnessed a land transaction between Benjamin Harrison and John Lewis Davis on Choestoa Creek tributary of the Tugaloo River, p. 203


July 1800, an 860 acre tract of land on the Tugaloo River originally surveyed for a Thomas Harrison was sold.  William Cleveland was a witness, p. 247


July 1802, Thomas Payne sold 101 acres to Thomas Harrison on Choestoa Creek.  Keys, Rolston and Bibb land noted.  Thomas Keys made oath to William Cleveland, J.P., p. 282


October 1802, Lewis Rolston and Thomas Harrison complete a 12 acre land transaction on Tugaloo River formerly the property of Mr. Payne.  Witnesses were Godfrey and Hannah Isbell, p. 299
Note: This is likely Rev. War Captain Godfrey Isbell (Kings Mountain) and his wife Hannah Clark.  Godfrey's brother was Capt. Pendleton Isbell.  Pendleton Isbell served with my paternal ancestor in George Washington's elite Life Guards unit.


March 1806, Thomas Harrison and Ormand Morgan complete land and property transactions, land bounded by Harrison, Rolston and Peggy Echols, p. 406


Several transactions from Thomas Harrison to Benjamin Harrison, Jacob Holland, p. 262


The following are from the book Pendleton District and Anderson County, South Carolina, Wills Estates and Legal Records, by Virginia Alexander, Colleen Elliott and Betty Willie:


April 1809, Thomas Harrison, Sr., gives property to his son Benjamin Harrison in trust to William Harrison and his wife Elizabeth and their children.  John Varner (Verner) and Duncan Mackensie are noted.  Witnesses are John Cleveland, Clary Cleveland and Peggy Perkins.


September 1792, A Thomas Harrison appears to have appraised the inventory of John WoodsideMichael Darnell and Nathaniel Perry signed as well, p. 16


February 1836, Will of John B. Earle.  A Thomas Harrison is one of the executors.  This is probably not our Thomas Harrison – This is likely the Greenville lawyer and politician Thomas Harrison, p. 80


July 1811, A Thomas Harrison witnessed a land transaction between John Taylor and William Dunlap.  This appears to be land on 26 mile creek and is probably not our Thomas Harrison, p. 206


 

The following are per the book by Lois Helmers entitled Early Records of Franklin County, Georgia.


July 1780, Benjamin Harrison to William Bridges conveys 300 acres in Franklin County on the south side of the Tugaloo River.  Thomas Harrison, John Smith were witnesses and Larkin Cleveland was the J.P., p. 15.  Larkin Cleveland was probably the brother of Col. Benjamin and Rev. John.


February 1790, Thomas Harrison, Sr. and Thomas Harrison were witnesses to a land transaction between Newel Walton and Benjamin Harrison in Franklin County on Bear Creek, p. 21



Relevant Early Census Records

1790 Census, Pendleton District, SC


There are 2 Thomas Harrisons listed for Pendleton:


Thomas #1: This is probably Thomas, Sr. and he is listed living near Benjamin Cleveland, Moses Perkins, Isaac Perkins, Solomon Perkins, Capt. William Perkins, John Barton, Nathaniel Perry, John Harrison and John Guest – all of whom lived near the Tugaloo River and Beaverdam Creek.  Several of these names can also be found in the documents found for the Harrison family.  There is also a Mary Blair listed who might be related to the William Blair that married Thomas' granddaughter Catherine Harrison.


Thomas #2: This is probably Thomas, Jr. and he appears to be living not too far from Thomas Sr.  Other names shown living near him are (Capt) Moses Guest and William Guest, David Sloan, Capt. John Kees and John Cleveland. . Note that Capt. Guest and Capt. Kees were both at the battle of Kings Mountain as was Benjamin Cleveland.  Capt. Moses Guest is also my maternal line.


1800 Census, Pendleton District, SC


Again, there are 2 Thomas Harrisons listed for Pendleton:


Thomas #1:  Likely Thomas, Sr. as his age is shown to be 45+ and living near Aaron Terrell, Benjamin Harrison and John Harrison who are likely his sons.  A Lewis Davis is listed close by which is a name that can also be found on the 1790 census living close to Thomas #1.  Benjamin Perry's name is also shown nearby.


Thomas #2:  This is likely Thomas, Jr. as his age is shown to be 26-44.  Robert Harrison is the entry above him.  Thomas Harbin is on the same page.


1810 Census Pendleton District, SC


Only one Thomas Harrison is shown living in Pendleton and his age is shown to be 45+.  This Thomas is shown living near Benjamin Perry.  Other names close by are William Guest, William Cleveland, John Cleveland and Jeremiah Cleveland.  Some researchers claim that Thomas, Sr. died in 1810 so this is probably Thomas, Jr.  We have no proof that Thomas Harrison, Sr. died in 1810 but since he cannot be found on the 1810 census it seems likely that he died in the first part of 1810 before the census was taken.


1820 Census, Pendleton District, SC


We now again have 2 Thomas Harrisons living in Pendleton; However, I believe one of these Thomas' is the noted lawyer and politician who divided his time between Greenville and Pendleton.


Thomas #1 is shown to be 45+ and his household includes 9 slaves.  I believe this is Thomas, Jr. and his neighbors included George Cleveland, Samuel Earle, widow Harbin, and (General) Andrew Pickens.


Thomas #2: is shown to be 26-44 and his household includes 21 slaves.  I believe this Thomas is the noted lawyer.

 

1830 Census, Pendleton District, SC


We still have 2 Thomas Harrisons, one now with 44 slaves which we know cannot be our Thomas, Jr.


Thomas #1: Age 60-69, 10 slaves, living near Soloman O'Kelly, Aaron Terrell, Moses Terrell, John Harrison, Nathaniel Perry, Benjamin Perry, Nathaniel Perry,  Col. Benjamin Cleveland, John Legrand and Thomas Harbin. This Thomas, is certainly our Thomas Harrison, Jr.


Thomas #2: With 44 slaves, this Thomas cannot be our Thomas - This is almost certainly the noted lawyer.


1840 Census, Pickens District, SC (Formerly Pendleton District)


Thomas #1: Age 70-79 with 8 slaves.  This is certainly our Thomas, Jr. The names of neighbors are George Cleveland, Shadrach Harrison, Benjamin Perry, Catherine Blair, Hugh Blair, Elias Earle – All names consistent with the earlier censuses and the same names which are found in the documents.


1840 Census, Franklin County, GA


The following names are found living fairly close together in District 213:


Signal A. Wilkinson
Oliver Harrison
Josiah Stovall
John T. Harrison
John M. Stovall
Jordan Farmer
Thomas Farmer


And in District 214, there is a Thomas Harrison (age 40-49) and a Mary Harrison (age 50-59).


This Mary could be the Mary that married Josiah Stovall and thus became Mary Stovall.  This Thomas might be her son or a nephew.


Note: I was not able to locate an 1800s era map of Franklin County that showed districts but I did find one from 1910 which clearly shows district 213 near The Tugaloo River and Gum Log Creek.  This area is where the graves of many of the descendants of Thomas Harrison can be found. Note that with the creation of Lake Hartwell, much of that district is now under water – The tip of Tugaloo State Park is the present day area that was closest to the original course of the Tugaloo River.



The Family of Thomas Harrison, Jr. and Nancy (lnu)
(Son of Thomas Harrison Sr. and Caty (lnu))


I am providing more details here on Thomas, Jr. the son of Thomas Sr and Caty because this branch is my direct line.  To date, I have not found any clue regarding the maiden name of Nancy; However, she was still alive when the 1850 census was taken and her age is noted as 80 (born about 1770) and born in New Jersey.  It is likely that Thomas and Nancy were married in SC.


There is a rather large estate file for Thomas when he died in 1841 in SC so we have the names of most, if not all, of his children.  (Note: The complete estate documents can be found on Ancestry.com.)


1.        Mary
2.        Catherine
3.        Clarissa/Clara
4.        Hepsie/Hepsy
5.        Lydia
6.        Elizabeth
7.        Shadrack/Shadrach
8.        Martin


The appraisers of Thomas' estate were George ClevelandE.P. Verner  and NJF Perry.  Martin Harrison (son) was the executor.  Other names of note listed in the estate documents are William LegrandThomas Farmer, Jordan FarmerWilliam Cleveland, James Harrison, Sr. and Signal Wilkinson.


George Cleveland is probably the son or grandson of Col. Benjamin Cleveland or Rev. John Cleveland.


E.P. Verner is Ebenezer Pettigrew Verner is the son of the Rev. War soldier and lawyer John Verner. (These Verners and the Pettigrew families (for which Ebenezer is named) are also my maternal lines: My grandparents were 4th cousins due to both having the same Verner and Pettigrew ancestry.)


NJF Perry is likely Josiah F. Perry, the brother of SC Governor Benjamin Franklin Perry, both sons of Benjamin Perry, Sr.  Interestingly, Josiah was initially buried in what was called the Terrell family cemetery which is now underneath Lake Hartwell but he was reinterred to Pleasant Grove Baptist Church where his father is buried.  Shadrach Harrison, Thomas' son, is supposedly also buried in this same cemetery although I was unable to locate his grave when I visited the cemetery some years ago.  Also note that Thomas' daughter Clarissa married Aaron Terrell and Aaron is also buried at Pleasant Grove Baptist Church.


Jordan Farmer married Martha Harrison, the daughter of Mary Harrison Stovall and thus Jordan is Thomas Harrison's grandson-in-law.


Signal Wilkinson is Thomas Harrison's grandson-in-law – Signal married Netty Harrison, daughter of Mary Harrison Stovall.


1.        Mary – Appears to have been born about 1780-1785.  Her first marriage may have been to a Harrison but she later married an elderly Josiah Stovall (and had no children between them).  Josiah and Mary appear to have married sometime in the 1840s and Josiah died a few years later – this was at least the 2nd marriage for both.  One of the children of Mary and the unknown Harrison male was Netty (short for Antoinette?) who married Signal A. Wilkinson, son of the Rev. war Sgt. Elisha Wilkinson.  Netty and Signal had Susan Wilkinson who married William C. Blair, the son of William Blair and Catherine Harrison (see below, another daughter of Thomas Jr.).  Thus, Susan Wilkinson and William C. Blair, husband & wife, were also 1st cousins, once removed.  Mary's son Oliver (who was the executor of her Will) is also listed in the estate documents of Thomas Harrison, Jr. - Oliver is Thomas' grandson.  Josiah Stovall is also noted in Thomas Harrison's estate documents as a payee for "for work done on the dec'd coffin".





Will of Mary Harrison Stovall, widow of unknown Harrison and Josiah Stovall
(Ancestry.com)

Estate documents of Thomas Harrison, Jr., 1846 naming beneficiaries.
Mary Stovall is likely his daughter but it is possible that she might be the widow of a son.
(Ancestry.com)


Note that Mary states that Martin Harrison has money that belongs to her - Martin is either her brother or brother-in-law (cannot prove which).  Martin was the executor for Thomas Harrison Jr.'s estate so he might still have money due her from that estate which is what she is referring to above.

2.        Catherine – Married William Blair.  She was born about 1790 and she died sometime after 1870.  William Blair died in 1835.  See above – her son married his 1st cousin Netty Harrison, daughter of Catherine's sister Mary Harrison Stovall.  William Blair was a War of 1812 soldier (Georgia).  Their son William C. Blair was a Confederate soldier that probably died as a POW at Elmira NY.


3.        
Clarissa/Clara – Born about 1792.  She married Aaron Terrell, Jr. (B. 1790; D. 1860).  Aaron was the son of Rev War soldier Aaron Terrell, Sr.  Aaron Jr's Will indicates he lived at the confluence of Sugar Creek and the Tugaloo River.


4.        
Hepsie/Hepsey – born 1813 and died 1890.  She married Elam Farmer (B.1805;D.1857).  Hepsie is buried at Poplar Springs Baptist Church, Franklin County, GA.  Elam is buried in the Farmer-Stovall Family Cemetery in the Gum Spring community of Franklin County, GA.


5.        
Lydia – married Spence Dortch. Lydia and Spence can be found on the 1840 census living in District 267 of Franklin County, GA, both aged 30-40.


6.        
Elizabeth – married John Legrand.  John might be the son of Rev. War soldier by the same name who is buried in present day Forsyth County. GA (NW of Cumming).


7.        
Shadrack/Shadrach – married Sarah Perkins daughter of William


8.        
Martin – born about 1810, he married Anne/Annie Maret.  Anne is buried at Beaverdam Baptist Church, Fairplay, SC.  She was born 1816 and died 1883.  Anne is probably a daughter or granddaughter of the Rev. War soldier Benjamin Maret/Marett who is also buried in the same cemetery.  Interestingly, Benjamin married a Harbin.



All In The Family

I found several family relationships that I have yet to unravel completely:


·      
Julia Stone married Hugh Blair.  Hugh was the son of William Blair and Catherine Harrison.

·       Susannah Stone married Oliver Harrison.  Oliver was the son of Mary Harrison, the sister of Catherine Harrison (above).

·       Steven Maret (Marett) married Martha Blair, the daughter of William Blair and Catherine Harrison.  A John Maret lived next to Mary Harrison (later Mary Stovall) on the 1840 census.  Steven and John are likely brothers.  They are both buried at the Beaverdam Baptist Church near Fairplay, SC.  They are sons or grandsons of the Rev War soldier Benjamin Marett.

·       Anne/Anna Marett married Martin Harrison.  Martin is the son of Thomas Harrison, Jr.  Anne is likely the daughter of the Rev. War soldier Benjamin Marett.

·       Elizabeth Harrison, the daughter of Oliver and Susannah Stone, married James M. Farmer the son of Elam Farmer and Hepsie Harrison (dau of Thomas Harrison, Jr.). This is another 1st cousin, once removed, marriage.  Oliver was the son of Mary who was the sister of Hepsie.

·       William Blair the husband of Catherine Harrison is noted in the Will of Absalom Cleveland.  The relationship between Absalom and William is unknown: They apparently lived close together but that may have been the extent of the relationship.

·       William Blair's land in Franklin County, GA is noted in the Will of David Barton. Unknown if any relationship exists between these 2 men.

·       There are numerous entries for William Cleveland in the estate documents of Thomas Harrison, Jr.   The Cleveland-Harrison relationship is known for Thomas Harrison, Sr. and several of his children but unknown if any direct relationship exists for Thomas Harrison, Jr.

·       Jordan Farmer, the brother of Elam Farmer, married a Legrand.  Elam Farmer married Hepsie Harrison the daughter of Thomas Harrison, Jr.

·       In the Will of Lucy Abernathy Wilkinson, the mother-in-law of Netty Harrison Wilkinson the names Jordan Farmer and Josiah Stovall can be found.  Josiah Stovall's 1st wife was said to be Lucy Farmer.

Will of Lucy Abernathy Wilkinson, wife of Sgt. Elisha Wilkinson, parents of Signal A. Wilkinson
Signal married Nettie Harrison the daughter of Mary Harrison and an unknown Harrison male.  
Mary was the 2nd wife of Josiah Stovall
(Ancestry.com)


Signal Wilkinson is also listed in the estate documents of Thomas Harrison, Jr. which likely indicates the familial relationship of Signal being the husband of Thomas' granddaughter (Netty).


Lastly, it appears that there was a land dispute that the Harrison family decided to settle outside the legal framework.  While it is true that laws were few back in the frontier days, it was apparently within the purview of the legal system to make arrest for trespassing and using force and/or threat of bodily harm.



Anne K. McCuen, Jane E. Kirkman, Penelope Forrester, Abstracts of General Sessions Court Case Rolls, Washington District South Carolina 1792-1799



This appears to be Thomas Harrison Jr., his brother William and possibly William's wife Elizabeth.  Note that the Justice of the Peace is neighbor John Verner, my 4th great-granduncle.   William and Elizabeth, with the help of Thomas, took possession of the dwelling using force.  William pled guilty but it is not shown if he had to give up the dwelling.  Just a guess on my part but the document says that they were hired laborers for Frederick Lanier so he might not have paid them and they decided to make claim to his property in return?  Or, he may have promised the land to William and reneged on the deal.  Knowing the Harrison family as I do, it seems improbable to me that they just decided to take possession of another man's property without provocation or reason.


__________________________________________

Key to Map
1. Pleasant Grove Baptist Church
2. Col. Benjamin Cleveland land
3 & 4 Cemeteries of Sgt. Elisha Wilkinson and the Farmer-Stovall family
5. Poplar Springs Baptist Church
6. Memorials to Rev. War soldiers at SC Welcome Center
7. Beaverdam Baptist Church


(This page was updated on 1/16/2023)